Eddie Martini's: Upscale Dining Experience in Wauwatosa

There aren’t many “old-fashioned” classy restaurants like EM’s anymore. We’ve been eating here for decades on special occasions as the service is exceptional. (Note: it’s not really a good atmosphere for kids). It’s a bit pricey and suggest you inquire costs of specials before ordering if you are on a budget. However, we always get the same dishes so know ahead of time of the meal investment. Two of them shown are the griddled Brie and the seafood tower.

Always a wonderful experience. We called last-minute for reservations and they got us right in. Greeted us with a smile and a hey you two, how have you been? Fabulous steaks as always.

This was our first time here. Food was fabulous. I had the Ribeye and my husband had the Strip Trio. Both were fabulous. Before the main course, my husband had the Baked French Onion soup which was wonderful and I had the Lobster Bisque which was stupendous. Although it was far for is to drive, I feel we will definitely dine here again.

Food was excellent. The seafood tower is totally worth it. Dylan went above and beyond.

Fantastic cozy place to spend an evening, and enjoy an amazing meal. The service was exceptional at Eddie Martini’s, as we had two lovely servers. The French onion soup is to die for! This was by far the best French onion I’ve had, as the bread in the broth was still crunchy! Their filet mignon is easily the best I’ve had, especially as someone who gets it done “Well”. The butter they pour over the filet is so delicious. Dessert to finish out the evening was amazing as well. Their restrooms are very clean and private. 100% recommend!

Eddie Martini’s is one of the top old-school supper club–style steakhouses in the Milwaukee area and an excellent choice for private dining. The atmosphere is classic and upscale, and the first-class service truly sets it apart—polished, attentive, and professional without feeling stuffy. The food never disappoints: the lobster mac is rich and indulgent, the 10oz filet is cooked perfectly and packed with flavor, and the chocolate cake dessert is an absolute must-have to finish the meal. A true Milwaukee-area staple for a timeless steakhouse experience.

This is my top choice for steak dinners in Milwaukee. I’ve been roughly ten times in the last two years and only have great things to say. Only reason I haven’t gone every week is to not get spoiled! Service has been excellent - the staff is incredibly knowledgeable and so welcoming. Chefs know their stuff and from start to finish, the food is some of the best I’ve had in my life. Great smaller scaled setup makes the atmosphere more intimate and enjoyable, while still having good space. Drinks are excellent as well and it’s very reasonably priced, couldn’t ask for much more. Eddies is incredible!

A wonderful steak house with beautifully prepared steaks and top notch service. I had the dry aged steak medium rare and I was very impressed. It was like eating butter and was cooked perfectly. I also enjoyed the escargot as an appetizer. The server was very attentive and anticipated my needs well Overall, I really enjoyed this special dinner. I would definitely visit again.